Former Yankees Prospect Having Dream Rookie Season With Rockies

It’s clear that the Rockies are still in limbo and a bottom feeder team, but that could very well change soon. 

TJ Rumfield may be a bit old to be considered a rookie at 26-years-old, but the former top Yankees prospect has quietly been tearing things up in the NL this season. A 2.4 WAR in 95 games is accompanied by a .296 batting average (99-for-335), and an OPS of .855. Playing first base primarily this season, Rumfield has been near-perfect. In 667.1 innings at first base, he has a .995 fielding percentage, with only 3 errors on his stat sheet.

Despite his breakout rookie campaign that has earned him consecutive NL Rookie of the Month honors, Rumfield has just simply slipped through the cracks. With first basemen such as Bryce Harper and Freddie Freeman, it is understandable how and why he was overlooked for All-Star consideration, but what a shame it really is. Colorado may not be contenders this season, but they have themselves a possible franchise player if his performance keeps up. Also, Rumfield’s rookie status is still intact through 2026, so while he may not be an All-Star, expecting a Rookie of the Year nod is most certainly in the equation.

Seeing how the Yankees have been during the late June swoon that followed them into July, it is clear that they need a hitter like Rumfield – the saddest fact though is that they had Rumfield himself. As mentioned earlier in the article, TJ Rumfield was a top Yankees prospect.

New York acquired Rumfield in an offseason November trade that would send Nick Nelson to the Phillies. Rumfield went as high as Triple-AAA for New York and most notably won a minor league Gold Glove award while he was in Double-AA with Somerset. 

Rumfield spent all of 2025 with SWB, and played 138 games for the RailRiders. He slashed .285/.378/.447 with an .825 OPS and 87 RBIs. Rumfield played in 10-more games than anyone else on the team, and had nearly 20-more hits than the closest player in comparison.

The Yankees shipped off Rumfield in January for Angel Chivilli, who has impressed so far in limited time in the Majors. Despite being a career 6.18 pitcher coming into New York, Chivilli has posted a 1.17 ERA across 6 games and 7.2 innings.

While Chivilli has so far pitched well, the Yankees have been in desperate need of consistent hitting this season. If New York kept Rumfield, he likely would be in the Majors for the Yankees right now, but it would also likely have come with decreased playing time than what he is getting right now with the Rockies.

Subscribe to our YouTube (IT’S FREE) here.